Showing posts with label Re'eh. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Re'eh. Show all posts

Chiasm in 1 Timothy 6

 

  • v3-5 - Beware of false teachers
    • v6-12 - Warning to the rich
      • v13 - Praises to God/Jesus
        • v14 - Keep the commandments until Jesus appears
      • v15-16 - Praises to God/Jesus
    • v17-19 - Warning to the rich
  • v20-21 - Beware of false teachings


A Parallelism within a Chiasm in Deuteronomy 12





  • V1-4 – Follow God’s ways not pagan ways.
    • V5-7 – Take your sacrifices & offerings to the place God will designate
      • V8-14 – Don’t offer sacrifices just anywhere, but only in my place
        • V15a – Slaughter & eat meat anywhere
          • V15b – Clean & unclean alike just like gazelle & deer
            • V16 – Don’t eat blood
      • V17-19 – Don’t eat offerings just anywhere, but only in my place
        • V20-21 – Slaughter & eat meat anywhere
          • V22 – Just like gazelle & deer, clean & unclean alike
            • V23-25 – Don’t eat blood
    • V26-27 – Take offerings to the place God will designate
  • V28-32 – Follow God’s ways, not pagan ways.

A few thoughts:

Rashi and the Sages
v8 - You shall not do according to all that we are doing here today, everyone doing whatever is right in his own eyes...
Rashi said that this verse should be translated "...rather everyone should do whatever is right in his own eyes..." which seems to be precisely the opposite of what is intended. The Jewish sages, including Rashi, frequently have amazing insight into Torah. They have been studying it for more than 3000 years, after all. Unfortunately, 3000 years provides a lot of opportunity for corruption as well. I think this is an example of the latter rather than the former.

The sages also say that the laws in v8-25 are specifically addressing animals that were vowed to be offered at the Tabernacle, but had to be redeemed because of some flaw that developed or was discovered later. This law was given so that the one making the vow would not feel like the animal must still be treated as sacred somehow, hence the explicit allowance for the unclean to eat it.
The unclean and the clean may eat of it as of the gazelle and as of the deer.
That seems reasonable enough, but if it's correct, then it was probably only the initial reason the law was recorded in the way that it was. The rule still applies to all non-sacrificial animals regardless.

Where I think they get off track again is in the reference to the gazelle and the deer. Here they reference a tradition in which the right front leg, cheeks, and stomach of a slaughtered cow, sheep, or goat must be given to a Cohen, while the same is not true of a gazelle or deer. This formerly dedicated animal may be kept in whole without giving a portion to a Cohen.

There's nothing wrong with giving a portion of your slaughtered animals to the local Cohen--it might even be a good thing--but it is only a tradition, not a Torah command, and I do not believe that Moses had even the vaguest notion of this practice when he gave this commandment. I think he meant something much more obvious.

Since gazelle and deer were not domesticated animals, it would have been next to impossible to take them to the Tabernacle to be slaughtered. Nobody would have captured these animals before killing them. They would have killed them in the field using some kind of blade or projectile. Moses was merely saying that in this respect a cow is no different than a deer. Just because it can be used as a sacrifice doesn't mean that it must be used so.

The Meaning of the Chiasm and Parallelism

I haven't been studying Biblical literary structures long enough to be confident in these conclusions. I even hesitate to call them conclusions; they're merely speculations.

The religion of YHWH is not random or haphazard. Although God doesn't micromanage every aspect of daily life, His religion is orderly and uniform. Certain forbidden practices will tend to encourage the development of pagan religious systems:
  • We must not collect the blood of a slaughtered animal for any purpose other than pouring it out onto the ground. Blood contains life. I won't pretend to know everything that that means, but there is definitely something about blood that inspires mystical thoughts and feelings. Ingesting blood can easily evolve into a religious ritual. Many old movie featuring hunting Indians or a young man's first kill witness to our cultural understanding of this truth. (Laboratory use of blood is fine so long as it is never ingested and it is disposed of when no longer needed.) 
  • Differentiating between kosher animals that are eligible for sacrifice and kosher animals that are not eligible for sacrifice in the routine practice of slaughtering for food could also easily evolve into a religious ritual. The butcher or the purchaser must ask himself why they are observing this difference. Perhaps the spirit of the bull must be treated differently than the spirit of the gazelle, so he begins saying a little prayer to the bull with the initial cut of the knife. His son builds a small shrine beside the killing floor. His grandson builds a platform on the killing floor to catch the blood. His great grandson dabs the blood on the four horns of the family altar and drinks a cup of the sanctified stuff. 
  • A difference must be made between sanctified animals and the non-sanctified. However, it is not the animal that makes the offering sacred but the altar. Sacrifices may only be killed and eaten in God's designated place and mundane slaughter may only be done and eaten away from God's designated place. Never mix the two lest the difference in the places be forgotten and the people slide again into paganism.
Now I'm going to really step out into Messianic controversy land. Because you know how I've shied away from that kind of stuff before. Wink, wink.

The contents of the parallelism make sense in the context of the chiasm as noted in the points above. However, why is there a parallelism at all? Why say essentially the same thing twice? The repetition means it's important of course, but wouldn't it be enough to simply say "This is really important?"

On the surface (peshat), the first iteration concerns where a sacrifice must be killed and the second concerns where it may be eaten. However, it goes on to repeat much of the same rules, including the curious reference to gazelle and deer.

The Law makes no distinction between the native born and the believer who has been grafted in except in one respect: service at the Holy Place. Only the physical descendants of Levi may serve at the Tabernacle and only the physical descendants of Aaron may serve at the altars. Through Yeshua, we have been brought into the Kingdom of God, grafted into the tree of Israel, but, like Yeshua, we will never be qualified to serve as a Cohen or to care for any of the holy articles of the Tabernacle. (Yeshua is a High Priest in the Tabernacle in Heaven, not the one on earth. See Hebrews 8:1-5.)

Likewise, this command says that as far as the Law is concerned, there is no difference between the gazelle and deer (wild & untaught) on the one hand and the bull and the goat (domesticated & trained) on the other, except in one respect: service at the Holy Temple. And it says it twice.

Is this parallelism attempting to draw the reader's attention to the parallel between animals and Israelites? Is it saying, "Whether in offering or in eating sacrifices, the positive commands and the negative commands, you will make no distinction in the Law between the native born and the grafted in except for those who are dedicated to service at the Holy Place?"

The parallelism is at the center of a chiasm which is framed by instructions that all citizens of the Kingdom will worship God in the same way and at the same place. We are one body, one nation, united in Messiah Yeshua.

The Designer Knows His Design

From Science Daily:
…A study shows that eating these animals can have side effects that call into question the wisdom of eating this ‘delicacy.’
God’s rules for what animals you should eat and what you shouldn’t are not about health. Let me say that again: Eating kosher isn’t about health. It’s about obedience. However, having said that, eating kosher is almost certainly healthier than not.
Exodus 15:26 And said, If thou wilt diligently hearken to the voice of the LORD thy God, and wilt do that which is right in his sight, and wilt give ear to his commandments, and keep all his statutes, I will put none of these diseases upon thee, which I have brought upon the Egyptians: for I am the LORD that healeth thee.

Thou Shalt Not Rationalize Your Paganism

Deuteronomy 12:4 You shall not do so to YHWH your God.
God told Israel to completely destroy the Canaanites’ places and articles of worship, then He told them not to incorporate pagan elements into His religion.

For most of the last two thousand years, the Roman Catholic Church has made such assimilation an integral part of their evangelism, while most of the rest of the Church played along. We justify our disobedience to God by pointing to the numbers of people professing faith or being baptized.

Today, Christianity is so thoroughly infected with pagan imagery and practice that, like fish who can't see the water, we rarely even know it.

God understands how adaptability can be used to make the Church more seeker-friendly, yet He still commanded us not to compromise in this way. Easter eggs, jack-o-lanterns, Christmas trees, etc. All of those things were adopted from pagan religions, yet we keep doing them, thinking that we are pleasing God. “He knows my heart.”

Except that God specifically said, “Don’t do those things and say you are doing them for me.”

War and Peace in the Promised Land



Deuteronomy 11:29-32 And it shall come to pass, when the LORD thy God hath brought thee in unto the land whither thou goest to possess it, that thou shalt put the blessing upon mount Gerizim, and the curse upon mount Ebal. Are they not on the other side Jordan, by the way where the sun goeth down, in the land of the Canaanites, which dwell in the champaign over against Gilgal, beside the plains of Moreh? For ye shall pass over Jordan to go in to possess the land which the LORD your God giveth you, and ye shall possess it, and dwell therein. And ye shall observe to do all the statutes and judgments which I set before you this day.
There is a common belief among Christians that Jesus will come and take us all away before anything really bad happens. God saved Noah from the flood and Lot from the brimstone and Israel from the plagues. I’ve got some bad news for you.

No. He didn’t.

He saved them through tribulation, not from it. Noah was locked up in a boat for months with seven other people and thousands of animals during the most violent storm the world has ever known. Lot walked out of Sodom and took shelter in a small town right while the sky rained down fire and brimstone all around them. The Israelites suffered a number of the plagues right alongside the Egyptians and then had to march through forty years of wilderness to reach the Promised Land. And what did they find when they finally got there? They found both blessing and curse. “Are they not on the other side of the Jordan?”

The Promised Land wasn’t paradise, but it was where God wanted them to be. It was where they needed to be. Growth doesn’t come through leisure, but through joy and suffering, loving and fighting, blessing and cursing.

Yes, there is a place where there are no more tears. But it’s not just over the rainbow rapture. It’s not in the Millennial Kingdom. God wants you to grow a little more between now and the end.

The Role of the Poor

When Yeshua said we will always have the poor with us, he wasn't necessarily being fatalistic. He wasn't commenting on greed or hopelessness. He was saying two things (that I can think of off the top of my head):

First, the poor–or rather, the less fortunate, because there is an extreme parsity of real poverty in America–will always be with us, because that's the way God wants it. Giving to the poor is a command and carries physical and spiritual benefits for the giver. God wants us to have an opportunity to experience those benefits, so he arranges for some people to have more than others. The "War on Poverty" and mass charities are misguided and counter to the way God wants charity to work. They actually create more poverty due to economic processes, which were probably designed by God in part to ensure that there would always be an upper and a lower economic class.

That doesn't necessarily mean that some people are destined to be poor while others destined to be wealthy, nor that we should never help the poor so much that they aren't poor anymore. I'm not talking about divine right and I'm not preaching Hinduism. It just means that we shouldn't worry too much about it. Don't try to save the world. Help those you can help personally, and let God take care of the rest.

Which leads me to the second point I believe Yeshua was making: keep your priorities straight. If everyone spent all their time helping the poor, then we would all very quickly become the poor. Everyone has their mission, their ministry, and it might change from time to time. You have to keep your eyes open, spiritual and physical, and realize that, no matter how emotionally charged a problem might be, there could be more important things for you to worry about. If every pilot or tanker ditched in order to pull a wounded soldier off the field, the war would soon be lost.